Thoughts, essays, and writings on Liberty. Written by the heirs of Patrick Henry.

“Have we the courage and the will to face up to the immorality and discrimination of the progressive tax, and demand a return to traditional proportionate taxation?”     Ronald Reagan

June 29, 2007

Did A National ID Card Kill The Immigration Bill ?

by Doug Mataconis

Among the many provisions of the recently defeated immigration bill that most Americans didn’t know about was a massive expansion of the use of a National ID card. And it seems that those provisions may have ultimately been what killed the bill:

The U.S. Senate definitively rejected President George Bush’s immigration bill on Thursday, just hours after senators expressed deep misgivings with portions that would have expanded the use of a national ID card.

Because the procedural vote was 46 to 53, with 60 votes needed to advance the immigration legislation, the proposal is likely to remain dead for the rest of the year.

Privacy advocates were quick to claim that a vote against Real ID cards the previous evening doomed the bill.

Wednesday’s vote showed that senators were willing to delete the portion of the labyrinthine immigration bill that would require employers to demand the Real ID cards from new hires. Because some of the bill’s backers had insisted that the ID requirement remain in place–as a way to identify illegal immigrants–they were no longer as willing to support the overall bill.

“The proponents of national ID in the Senate weren’t getting what they wanted, so they backed away,” said Jim Harper, a policy analyst at the free-market Cato Institute who opposes Real ID. “It was a landmine that blew up in their faces.”

The American Civil Liberties Union, another longtime foe of Real ID, said the Real ID requirements were a “poison pill that derailed this bill, and any future legislation should be written knowing the American people won’t swallow it.” Another section of the immigration bill would have given $1.5 billion to state officials to pay for Real ID compliance.

Regardless of what you think of any other provisions of the immigration bill, the fact that yet another back door attempt to create a National ID card was defeated is good news. Of course, the fight’s not over yet:

Even if the immigration bill is goes nowhere, however, the Real ID Act is still in effect. It says that, starting on May 11, 2008, Americans will need a federally approved ID card to travel on an airplane, open a bank account, collect Social Security payments or take advantage of nearly any government service.

States must conduct checks of their citizens’ identification papers and driver’s licenses may have to be reissued to comply with Homeland Security requirements. (States that agree in advance to abide by the rules have until 2013 to comply.)

Let the fight continue.

TrackBack URI:
Read more posts from
• • •


  1. Of all the aspects of this immigration bill to focus on, you pick the most obscure?

    C’mon. I doubt any Congressman or Senator even gave a thought to this aspect of the legislation, with their phones ringing off the hook in opposition to amnesty.

    How about some commentary on what really matters: the amnesty provisions.

    Comment by Robert Standard — June 29, 2007 @ 10:10 am
  2. [S]tarting on May 11, 2008, Americans will need a federally approved ID card to travel on an airplane, open a bank account, collect Social Security payments or take advantage of nearly any government service.

    I don’t really see the big deal with this, outside of the extra layer of bureaucracy. I already need an ID card to do any of these things. Heck, I needed to have to forms of ID to open a basic checking account in my hometown, where half of the people there know who I am anyway. We gave up being a society based on honesty and trust a long time ago.

    Comment by Joshua Holmes — June 29, 2007 @ 10:25 am

Comments RSS

Subscribe without commenting

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

Powered by: WordPress • Template by: Eric • Banner #1, #3, #4 by Stephen Macklin • Banner #2 by Mark RaynerXML