Why Democracy And Individual Liberty Usually Aren’t Compatible

Sometimes, the wisdom of crowds is as bad as the insanity of a dictator:

Nearly half of Americans (47%) believe the government should require all radio and television stations to offer equal amounts of conservative and liberal political commentary, but they draw the line at imposing that same requirement on the Internet. Thirty-nine percent (39%) say leave radio and TV alone, too.


Fifty-seven percent (57%) say the government should not require websites and blog sites that offer political commentary to present opposing viewpoints. But 31% believe the Internet sites should be forced to balance their commentary

If the First Amendment were put to a popular vote today, I doubt that it would get a majority.

  • http://kponly.blogspot.com Ryan

    If the First Amendment were put to vote, it would get a majority… Americans pride themselves on having freedoms they don’t understand.

  • http://pith-n-vinegar.blogspot.com/ Quincy

    Well, this is why that little vein in my forehead starts twitching every time I hear someone say we live in a democracy. We’ve totally failed to teach that there are some things to sacred to vote on, and I fear we’re going to pay for it sooner rather than later.

  • http://www.no-treason.com Joshua Holmes


    Don’t be silly. Athens had democracy without elections. In fact, they were convinced elections were a tool of oligarchs.

  • publius

    By the way we live in a Republic…or what’s left of it.

  • http://www.no-treason.com Joshua Holmes

    “Republic” does not mean “free”. The USSR was a republic. So was Khmer Rouge Cambodia. So is Zimbabwe.

  • http://pith-n-vinegar.blogspot.com/ Quincy

    Joshua –

    Given that the most people mean “we vote to make decisions” when they say “we live in a democracy”, I feel perfectly fine in my cringing whether you approve or not. Would you not agree that we’ve done a terrible job of holding the line on things to sacred to vote on?